A Complete Comparison of the Quatish Unbreakable Set, Amazon Basics 18-Piece Set, and Corelle Winter Frost
Choosing the right dinnerware set can completely elevate your kitchen experience — from casual breakfasts to holiday dinners. Amazon offers hundreds of options, but some stand out due to popularity, durability, and customer satisfaction.
Today, we’re reviewing three top Amazon picks, including the Amazon’s Choice dinnerware set and two of Amazon’s Best-Selling options:
- Quatish 12-Piece Unbreakable Dinnerware Set (Amazon’s Choice)
- Amazon Basics 18-Piece Dinnerware Set (Best Seller)
- Corelle Winter Frost White 18-Piece Set (Best Seller)
Let’s explore each one — what makes them popular, what they’re best for, and which set gives the best value.
- 16 Piece Dinnerware Set, Service for 4: Includes 4 round dinner plates, 4 Salad plates, 4 bowls and 4 cups. With a light…
- Durable and Kid-Friendly: Nearly unbreakable, shatterproof plastic dinnerware set with raised edges, resistant to chippi…
- Dishwasher and Microwave Safe: These plates and bowls sets can also go in the fridge or freezer. Offer convenient cleanu…
- Upscale Everyday Dining: Stylish plates suitable for various occasions, from parties and family gatherings to casual dai…
1. Quatish 16-Piece Unbreakable Dinnerware Set (Amazon’s Choice)
The Quatish dinnerware set earned the Amazon’s Choice badge for its combination of durability, safety, and everyday practicality. Made from eco-friendly wheat straw material, this set is lightweight, stackable, and virtually unbreakable — making it a favorite for families and everyday kitchen use.
Key Features
- 16-piece set: 8 plates, 4 bowls, 4 cups
- Unbreakable, lightweight material (wheat straw + PP)
- Microwave- and dishwasher-safe
- Stackable and space-saving design
- Modern pastel color options
What We Like
- Extremely durable — great for homes with kids or pets.
- Cups, bowls, and plates are light and easy to handle.
- Eco-friendly material with a smooth finish.
- Perfect for everyday meals or outdoor use.
What Could Be Better
- Not as heavy or premium-feeling as porcelain.
- Cups are smaller than traditional mugs.
Best For
Families, apartments, dorms, and anyone who needs practical, lightweight, break-resistant dinnerware.
- 18-piece dinnerware set with Branches pattern provides service for 6
- AB-grade porcelain combines a lightweight feel with durable strength
- Dishwasher-safe, freezer-safe, and microwave-safe for convenient everyday use
- Plates can withstand heat up to 572 degrees F
2. Amazon Basics 18-Piece Porcelain Dinnerware Set (Best Seller)
This Amazon Basics porcelain set remains one of the most popular dinnerware options on the platform. It’s a simple, elegant, and affordable choice that works for both everyday dining and hosting guests.
Key Features
- 18-piece set: service for 6 (dinner plates, salad plates, bowls)
- High-quality porcelain
- Microwave, freezer, oven, and dishwasher safe
- Lightweight yet durable construction
- Classic glossy white finish
What We Like
- Clean, timeless design that matches any table setting.
- Multi-use porcelain safe for heating food in the oven or microwave.
- Excellent value for large families or guests.
- Looks more premium than its price.
What Could Be Better
- Bowls are a bit shallow for soups.
- More prone to chipping than the Corelle set.
Best For
Homes that want affordable, elegant daily dinnerware with a classic design that fits any décor.
- 18 piece set includes 6 dinner plates, 6 appetizer/snack plates, 6 soup/cereal bowls
- In go-with-everything classic white, this is the dinnerware set that takes you from everyday meals to casual get-togethe…
- Nothing-else-like-it, triple-layer-strong glass plates and bowls highly resist chips and cracks
- Lightweight and easy to handle
3. Corelle Winter Frost White 18-Piece Set (Best Seller)
The Corelle Winter Frost set is a long-standing best seller known for legendary durability. Using triple-layer Vitrelle glass, this set is ultra-light, chip-resistant, and designed to last many years — even in busy kitchens.
Key Features
- 18-piece set: service for 6
- Vitrelle triple-layer tempered glass
- Chip-, crack-, and stain-resistant
- Microwave and dishwasher safe
- Thin, space-saving profile
What We Like
- Incredibly durable — plates rarely break or chip.
- Surprisingly lightweight yet strong.
- Stacks compactly, saving cabinet space.
- Minimalist white design works for casual or formal dining.
What Could Be Better
- Some people prefer a heavier feel.
- Sudden temperature shocks (red-hot stovetop) should be avoided.
Best For
Anyone looking for long-term, break-resistant dinnerware that stays looking new for years.
Final Comparison — Which Dinnerware Set Is Best?
| Product | Best For | Strengths | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quatish Unbreakable Set | Families, kids, outdoor use | Lightweight, unbreakable, microwave-safe | Not premium-looking |
| Amazon Basics 18-Piece | Everyday home use | Elegant, affordable, versatile | Can chip over time |
| Corelle Winter Frost | Long-term durability | Chip-resistant, ultra-light, long-lasting | Very lightweight feel |
My Recommendation
- For families → Quatish is the safest and most durable.
- For stylish everyday home use → Amazon Basics porcelain gives the best appearance at a low price.
- For long-term investment → Corelle is the most durable and space-efficient.
✔ Final Thoughts
Your perfect dinnerware set depends on your priorities:
- Want unbreakable, family-safe dishes? Choose Quatish.
- Want classic porcelain for everyday use? Choose Amazon Basics.
- Want plates that last 10+ years without chipping? Choose Corelle.
All three are strong options, but the differences in material, durability, and weight help you decide what fits your home best
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you